Aspartame advice unchanged despite cancer question
Picture credit, Getty Images
Kids are particularly vulnerable to surpassing the acceptable levels of aspartame present in low-calorie beverages.
Health and science reporter
The recommendations regarding the permissible consumption of aspartame remain unaltered, despite the sweetener being labeled as "potentially" linked to cancer.
Two teams of specialists at the World Health Organization have undertaken the examination of numerous scientific studies.
The designation of "potentially cancer-causing" frequently elicits apprehension and bewilderment, yet it simply indicates that the supporting data lacks persuasiveness.
The majority of individuals consume aspartame in quantities below the designated safe thresholds. However, the World Health Organization advises individuals who heavily consume aspartame to reduce their intake.
Aspartame can be commonly found in the diet and sugar-free varieties of food products, as this substance provides a sweetness that is 200 times stronger than sugar, while containing minimal calories.
Well-known labels that consist of the sugar substitute are Diet Coke, Coke Zero, Pepsi Max, and 7 Up Free. However, aspartame can be found in approximately 6,000 different items, which vary from toothpaste and chewing gums to yogurts and cough drops.
Although it has gained extensive usage, there has been a considerable amount of debate surrounding the safety of this chemical ever since its introduction in the 1980s.
I inquired with Dr. Francesco Branca, the head of the nutrition and food safety division at the World Health Organization (WHO), about which option is more beneficial for health: sugar or artificial sweeteners?
He said to me: "When given the choice between artificially sweetened cola or cola with sugar, I believe there should be another alternative, like opting for water instead and reducing the intake of sugary beverages altogether."
He mentioned that the evaluations had "signaled a warning" about aspartame potentially being detrimental to your well-being, but assured that you need not worry about indulging in an occasional diet beverage or any other item that includes this sweetener. He further emphasized that "the issue arises for those who consume it excessively".
The initial organization to evaluate the proofs consisted of the cancer specialists of WHO, known as the International Agency for Research on Cancer.
The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) employs four potential categorizations:
Aspartame has now been classified in the same category as aloe vera and lead, being potentially cancer-causing. The basis for this classification primarily relies on three research studies that indicate a potential link to a specific form of liver cancer.
Nonetheless, the term "possibly" solely pertains to the level of scientific support. In the event of strong evidence, aspartame would have been placed in a more elevated classification.
According to Dr. Mary Schubauer-Berigan, a researcher at the International Agency for Research on Cancer, the available information is not of the best quality or convincing enough. This statement basically serves as an invitation to the scientific community to conduct further studies on the sweetener.
The categorization of cancer often results in misleading news titles. Alcohol and plutonium fall under the same group (both being known to cause cancer), although one is significantly more hazardous than the other.
Therefore, an independent organization known as the Joint Expert Committee on Food Additives, which is composed of the World Health Organization and the Food and Agriculture Organization, is responsible for determining the appropriate and secure quantities.
The study examined the chances of getting cancer as well as other concerns like cardiovascular conditions and type 2 diabetes. However, it concluded that there was no substantial justification to modify the guidance that has been in place since 1981.
Therefore, the recommended threshold stays at 40 mg for every kilogram of your weight on a daily basis.
These figures represent the maximum safety thresholds rather than set goals. However, considering the recommendations are determined by body weight, children find it comparatively simpler to approach these limits.
According to Dr. Branca, it is not advisable to keep a bottle of sugary carbonated beverage on the table during family meals, as this could lead children to develop a lifelong preference for sweets.
Furthermore, he emphasized that comprehensive assessments of the evidence indicate that sweeteners do not contribute to weight loss for individuals.
According to him, it is recommended for everyone to transition to a diet with decreased sweetness, which involves reducing the intake of both sugar and sweeteners. He also suggests that food companies should focus on creating flavorful products that are lower in sweetness.
A major unresolved research inquiry revolves around the potential link between aspartame and cancer (assuming there is one). The findings from the World Health Organization reveal that aspartame is swiftly metabolized in the digestive system, breaking down into three alternative substances: phenylalanine, aspartic acid, and methanol.
However, these are also the result of consuming a diverse range of other food items that are not associated with cancer. Furthermore, the experts determined that aspartame does not directly cause cancerous changes in a person's DNA. One potential factor could be the elevation of inflammation levels within the body.
According to Frances Hunt-Wood, who serves as the secretary general of the International Sweeteners Association, the research has once more validated the safety of aspartame.
She stated that Aspartame, similar to all sweeteners with low or no calories, offers consumers the opportunity to cut down on their sugar consumption, which is an important goal for public health, when incorporated as a part of a well-rounded diet.
There exist individuals who cannot consume aspartame without posing a risk to their well-being. These individuals are afflicted with an inherited disorder known as phenylketonuria or PKU, which prevents them from effectively processing the phenylalanine that is generated during the breakdown of aspartame.
